No Federal Funding for Planned Parenthood

Planned Parenthood sold baby parts and should be stripped of funding, so finds a select U. S. House investigative panel.

One of the first actions of the 115th Congress was the release of a report by a Select Investigative Panel of the Energy and Commerce Committee. The subject of the report wasn’t, as the committee’s name might suggest, about fracking or trade but something much more important — the sanctity and dignity of human life. Specifically, it was about revelations of likely wrongdoing by Planned Parenthood, in particular, but not only, the sale of fetal body parts.

As you probably know by now, these practices came to light as the result of undercover videos made by the Center for Medical Progress. In the videos, Planned Parenthood employees and officials discussed the prices parts of aborted fetuses could fetch, often in a matter of fact, bordering on the cavalier, fashion.

The least troubling was a pattern of over-billing Medicaid and other healthcare funding programs to the tune of $132 million dollars. More serious and far more troubling is Planned Parenthood’s disregard for the National Organ Transplant Act. The Act provides that “[i]t shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation if the transfer affects interstate commerce.”

Any fair-minded viewing of the Center’s videos would lead one to the conclusion that there is enough evidence to support a case that Planned Parenthood broke the law based on, what lawyers call, prima facie evidence. Certainly, there was enough evidence to warrant future investigations, which did not happen under the Obama administration. Instead, it was the people who brought the possible violations of the law to the public’s attention who were prosecuted. Perhaps “persecuted” would be the better word, given the absurdity of the changes, all of which were dropped or dismissed.

For these and many other reasons, including the impact of selling fetal tissue on the obtaining of patient consent, the Select Investigative Panel recommended that Congress strip Planned Parenthood of federal funding. In addition, it recommended that Congress take action to ensure that all donations of fetal tissue are made with informed consent, and that it clarify abortion law to ensure “abortion businesses do not harm women in order to procure fetal tissue.” It also called on Congress to pass legislation outlawing abortion after twenty weeks, and to establish “criminal penalties to enforce the Born-Alive Infants Protection Act.”

How likely is Congress to act on these recommendations? I don’t know, and I’m somewhat troubled by Speaker Ryan’s statement that defunding Planned Parenthood will be part of a larger attempt to repeal Obamacare. I’m thankful for his public statements, but the defense of human life and dignity should never be held hostage to another political fight.

Still, the Panel’s reports and the recommendations are an encouraging sign of how the political argument about abortion may have begun to shift in keeping with the broader cultural shift towards life. A decade ago, abortion on demand was considered legally and politically unassailable. Today, it’s hard to miss the note of panic among the defenders of the abortion regime. Praise God for that.

[This BreakPoint Commentary by John Stonestreet was posted on January 10, 2017 at]

[Early in 2016, Oregon Right to Life began an investigation of Oregon Health & Science University’s (OHSU) involvement with buying body parts from babies aborted at Lovejoy Surgicenter in Portland. Generous donations have been given by many pro-lifers in response to ORTL’s request to help finance this investigation. OHSU is taking an extremely long time in responding to the public information requests, however the investigation is still moving forward. Oregon Right to Life’s lawyers are still actively pursuing all legal resources to finalize this investigation.]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

get involved

Sign Up and Stay Informed